Black Friday BNPL Boom Could Drag Down Credit Scores — What That Means for Retail & Market Flow

Why this Black Friday may carry hidden costs

Over the 2025 holiday shopping blitz, many consumers — especially younger buyers — are leaning on Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) services via platforms like Klarna, Affirm, and PayPal to spread out big-ticket purchases.

But this holiday-friendly payment option is no longer off the radar. Starting this season, FICO is incorporating BNPL payment data into credit-score calculations. That means if you miss or pay late on installments, your credit could suffer — and quickly.

It’s not theoretical either: a recent LendingTree report found that 41% of BNPL users made late payments in the last year, underscoring how many buyers may be walking a fine line between convenience and credit risk.

Broader ripple effects: consumer balance sheets and retail demand under strain

When BNPL users begin to see credit-score damage, the consequences go beyond a harder time getting a loan or mortgage. Lower credit scores can translate to reduced access to other credit lines, which tends to hit discretionary spending hardest.

For retailers and consumer-facing businesses, that could mean a slowdown in repeat purchases or impulse buys — especially among younger demographics who lean most heavily on BNPL.

Worse, for companies that already depend on easy-credit-driven spending (fashion, electronics, home goods), the surge in delinquency risk could portend weaker holiday-season sales and muted growth ahead.

What this could look like in the markets & options flow

• Retail and consumer-discretionary names may start seeing pressure: if credit-young households retrench spending, earnings estimates could be revised down — leading to rising put interest, heavier skew, and lower call volume.
• BNPL-affiliated fintech or payment names may trade under volatility as default risk becomes more visible — watch for elevated open interest and possible gamma swings.
• Credit-sensitive sectors (autos, appliances, big-ticket items) could get hit if consumers with BNPL debt lose access to new credit or tighten budgets — meaning cautious sentiment, muted demand, and bearish positioning.
• “Staple” or defensive names — discount retailers, essentials, value-oriented chains — may prove relatively resilient, possibly attracting hedged flows or rotation from riskier names.

If you monitor options flow and gamma exposure on Unusual Whales, this shift may already seem baked into certain tickers — especially in retail and BNPL-adjacent space.

Watch this space: tickers that may move the fastest

• Major retail & consumer discretionary stocks — especially apparel, electronics, and home-goods retailers.
• Fintech / BNPL-linked payment firms — their valuation and volatility may rise in response to delinquency trends.
• Credit-sensitive sectors — autos, appliances, furniture, anything typically bought on installments or financing.
• Discount or essential-goods retailers and stable consumer staples could outperform if discretionary demand sinks.

If you use Unusual Whales to track these names — especially looking at open interest, skew, and flow — you might catch early signals of sentiment shifting.

Do you want to see how to make more plays? Do you want to find gains yourself?

Unusual Whales helps you find market opportunities through our market tide, historical options flow, GEX, and much, much more.

Create a free account on Unusual Whales to start conquering the market.

Bigger picture: BNPL is no longer fringe debt — it’s mainstream credit

The addition of BNPL data to FICO scores marks an inflection point: what once felt like “interest-free convenience” is now embedded in your credit profile. For the many Americans stretched thin this holiday season, a late installment could outlast the bargain they thought they scored.

If enough consumers get dinged, we could see a dampening of retail growth, which could ripple up through earnings, valuations, and options flow.