Sign in Subscribe

“Ghost Jobs” Are Plaguing Hiring — Market & Labor Signals Traders Need to Watch

Unusual Whales

• 3 min read
“Ghost Jobs” Are Plaguing Hiring — Market & Labor Signals Traders Need to Watch

“Ghost Jobs” Are Flooding Online Listings

Recent reporting spotlights a growing phenomenon in global labor markets: “ghost jobs” — job listings that look real but have no genuine intent to hire. These postings may stay live for weeks or months and generate flood of applications without ever leading to actual interviews or offers.

According to industry data cited alongside the BBC piece, as many as 20-22% of job ads online may fall into this category, either because the role is already filled, on hold, or simply never meant to be filled at all.

This trend has frustrated jobseekers, especially in competitive labor markets, and sparked debate over whether regulators should enforce stricter job-posting standards.

Why “Ghost Jobs” Exist

There are a few reasons behind the prevalence of these listings:

  • Data harvesting — Companies may collect candidate information even without hiring intent.
  • Branding or signaling — Some firms keep roles advertised to appear active or growing.
  • Poor ATS practices — Applicant tracking systems sometimes fail to remove outdated openings.

The result? Tens of millions of wasted applications, jobseekers left in limbo, and a labor market that looks looser than it actually is.

Divider

Do you want to see how to make more plays? Do you want to find gains yourself?

Unusual Whales helps you find market opportunities through our market tide, historical options flow, GEX, and much, much more.

Create a free account here to start conquering the market with Unusual Whales.
https://unusualwhales.com/login?ref=blubber

Why This Matters for Markets

At first glance, fake or outdated job postings may sound like a human-resources gripe. But there’s a market signal buried in this trend:

1. Labor Market Slack May Be Worse Than Reported
If a significant portion of advertised jobs never leads to hiring, official vacancy and job opening data overstate real labor demand. That could signal weaker employment growth than headline figures imply.

2. Wage Growth & Consumer Demand Signals
Labor confidence feeds into wage growth. If workers see fewer real opportunities, consumption may soften — a negative for consumer-linked stocks.

3. Sentiment & Risk Appetite
Underestimating labor market weakness can dampen sentiment, nudging traders toward defensive positions and boosting implied volatility in equities.

These signals often show up first in options flow and sentiment indicators before they show up in earnings reports or macro prints.

What Traders Should Watch on Unusual Whales

Labor market ambiguity and hidden slack can ripple through markets — especially in these sectors:

Consumer Spending & Retail Sentiment

Consumer demand softening due to labor uncertainty may show up as put skew expansions in these names.

Financials & Credit Exposure

Banks price loans based on labor confidence and wage growth — weak hiring can tighten credit conditions.

Options Flow Themes to Monitor

When labor market narratives turn murky, these patterns often emerge:

1. Volatility Expansion in Broad Indices
Uncertainty around jobs and openings can lift implied volatility in indexes like the S&P 500 as traders hedge risk.

2. Put Demand in Consumer Names
Consumer discretionary and retail stocks often show elevated put buying when spending forecasts weaken.

3. Skew Adjustments Around Economic Releases
Ahead of official reports (JOLTS, ADP, Non-farm Payrolls), traders may reposition via calendar and diagonal spreads, anticipating revisions to labor narratives.

Unusual Whales data can reveal these shifts before they show up in price action.

Labor Market Reality vs. Appearance

“Ghost jobs” highlight a deeper issue: not all advertised jobs represent real hiring intent. If job openings are overstated due to stale or deceptive postings, metrics like the JOLTS openings rate may be less reliable gauges of labor demand than assumed.

That’s important because labor health directly shapes:

  • consumer spending
  • wage inflation
  • Federal Reserve policy expectations
  • risk asset pricing

Traders who weigh true demand signals — beyond surface data — can find an edge.

Final Thoughts

Ghost jobs are more than a nuisance — they’re a potential signal of hidden slack in labor markets. And labor markets are a major driver of consumption, corporate profits, and credit conditions.

For traders, the lesson is the same:

Watch the underlying signal, not the headline.

When labor demand isn’t what it appears, risk sentiment and volatility often adjust first — in options markets and skew patterns — long before price charts reflect macro revisions.

Call to Action

Want to track these signals before broader markets react?

Unusual Whales gives you historical options data, implied volatility analytics, GEX indicators, and real-time market tide insights — the tools traders use to spot shifts before price moves.

Create your free Unusual Whales account and start uncovering opportunities:
https://unusualwhales.com/login?ref=blubber

Sign up for more like this.

Enter your email
Subscribe