Goldman Sachs Trading Desk Says Confidence in AI Is Fading as Chip Stocks Price In Negative Earnings Growth
The Desk's Read
Goldman Sachs' trading desk says confidence in the AI theme is fading fast.
"Judging by conversations with clients last week, sentiment around the theme is about as negative as we've seen in quite some time, and we're seeing that pessimism reflected more clearly in positioning and valuations," the desk wrote.
The note, from Goldman's flow desk, describes a sharp reversal in how clients are talking about the trade that powered the market for three years.
Priced for Decline
The starkest number is in the valuations.
Goldman's chart shows AI chip stocks are now priced for negative earnings growth in two years. Wall Street's consensus forecasts still call for growth of about 30% over the same period.
Other work from the bank points the same way. Goldman's AI semiconductor basket has been trading at roughly 11 times expected 2028 earnings, well below the S&P 500 multiple, even as sell-side consensus still projects earnings growth above 30% for the sector.
In other words, the market is no longer paying for the forecasts analysts are publishing. Either the selloff has run ahead of the fundamentals, or investors are front-running a wave of estimate cuts.
Positioning Has Flipped
The pessimism is showing up in positioning, not just multiples.
Goldman prime brokerage data has shown technology as one of the most net-sold sectors in recent weeks, and the long-short ratio for US information technology stocks has fallen to its lowest level since 2016.
Trend-following funds have built roughly $3.9 billion in short exposure to the Nasdaq 100, near the most bearish levels seen since late 2018.
The Philadelphia Semiconductor Index has underperformed the S&P 500 by more than 30 percentage points since June, its largest relative drawdown since 2002.
Options and Market Impact
The desk's read lands at a delicate moment for the AI complex.
Nvidia reports earnings on Tuesday, its first report since Jensen Huang resigned, and the stock has already fallen about 30% from its October 6 peak. A weak guide would validate the market's new pricing. A strong one would squeeze a very crowded short.
Chip names across the board, including Advanced Micro Devices and Broadcom, are trading as if earnings are about to contract. Semiconductor funds like the VanEck Semiconductor ETF and the iShares Semiconductor ETF have absorbed the brunt of the de-risking, and index hedges through the Invesco QQQ Trust remain in demand.
For Goldman Sachs itself, the note is a sentiment marker rather than a forecast change. The bank's own strategists have argued in recent weeks that parts of the selloff look excessive relative to fundamentals, which sets up a direct clash between the desk's client read and the research view.
Bottom Line
When the Street's biggest trading desk says AI sentiment is as negative as it has been in quite some time, and chip stocks are priced for earnings to shrink while analysts still forecast 30% growth, one side of that gap has to give. Nvidia's earnings on Tuesday are the first real test of which side is right.
Sign up for Unusual Whales at https://unusualwhales.com/login?ref=blubber to track the flow into the print.