Only 2.2% of Mortgaged Homes Are Underwater, per Goldman Sachs
Only 2.2% of mortgaged homes are underwater, per Goldman Sachs.
In 2008, it was roughly 1 in 4.
The comparison captures how completely the US housing market has flipped since the financial crisis, when negative equity helped trigger a wave of foreclosures and a collapse in home prices.
A Balance Sheet Built on Equity
An underwater home is one where the owner owes more on the mortgage than the property is worth.
At the height of the housing bust, roughly 25% of mortgaged homes sat in that position, trapping owners who could not sell or refinance without bringing cash to closing.
Today's 2.2% reading means the overwhelming majority of borrowers hold positive equity, much of it built during the pandemic-era surge in home prices and locked in by years of principal paydown.
Industry data tells the same story. Roughly half of mortgaged homeowners are now considered equity-rich, meaning their loan balances sit well below their homes' values.
Why It Matters for the Economy
Negative equity is what turns a housing slowdown into a crisis.
Borrowers with equity can sell, refinance, or ride out a downturn. Borrowers without it default, and forced sales drag prices down for everyone else.
With only 2.2% of homes underwater, the feedback loop that powered the 2008 collapse is largely absent, even as high mortgage rates keep transactions frozen and sellers outnumber buyers in many markets.
That cushion is a key reason forecasters see limited foreclosure risk even if prices soften from here. Homeowners, in aggregate, are simply not leveraged the way they were in 2008.
The Caveats
The equity cushion is not evenly spread.
Recent buyers who purchased at peak prices with small down payments in the hottest pandemic markets carry the thinnest buffers, and a sharp local price correction could push the underwater share higher in those pockets.
High rates also cut both ways. They discouraged the speculative borrowing that inflated the last bubble, but they have locked millions of owners into low-rate loans they cannot afford to leave, keeping inventory scarce.
What It Means for Markets
A resilient homeowner balance sheet is broadly supportive for housing-linked stocks and bank credit quality.
Homebuilders LEN, DHI, and PHM benefit from the inventory shortage that equity-rich, rate-locked sellers create, since new construction fills the gap resale homes cannot.
For lenders, low negative equity means mortgage credit losses stay contained. Watch options flow in XLF and big mortgage originators like JPM around housing data releases for how traders are pricing that resilience.
Housing sentiment trades, including XHB, tend to move on rate headlines, but the Goldman figure is a reminder that the sector's foundation is far sturdier than its crisis-era reputation.
The Bottom Line
One in four underwater borrowers defined 2008. Two in a hundred defines today.
That difference is the single biggest reason housing bears have been wrong about a repeat of the last crash.
Want to track how traders are positioning in housing and bank names? Create a free Unusual Whales account here and start conquering the market.