Owning a Home Now Costs Nearly $16K Extra Per Year — What That Means for Buyers, Renters & the Market

Unusual Whales

28 Nov 2025 • 3 min read

Homeowners Are Getting Hit With $16,000 in Hidden Costs

New data from a recent Zillow/Thumbtack analysis show that the average U.S. homeowner now spends about $15,979 per year on non-mortgage costs: insurance, property taxes, and upkeep.

Broken down, that’s roughly $10,946 for maintenance, $3,030 for property taxes, and $2,003 for homeowners insurance — more than $1,300 per month on top of mortgage payments.

In many expensive metro areas, that burden is even larger. For example, homeowners in certain coastal cities are seeing much higher total costs.

With hidden expenses rising about 4.7% over the last year — while household incomes rose just ~3.8% — many homeowners are getting squeezed.

Why This Changes the Homeownership vs. Renting Equation

🔧 Carrying Costs Outpacing Affordability

When upkeep, insurance, and taxes push total housing costs high, mortgage payment alone no longer defines affordability. Many prospective buyers are rethinking homeownership altogether.

For first-time buyers especially, the “sticker shock” may come after the purchase — surprise repairs, insurance hikes, tax increases — all stacking up.

🏠 Demand Shift: Renting Looks More Attractive

With ongoing costs stacking up, renting starts looking cleaner: fewer surprises, lower upfront burden, no maintenance bills. For many, that shifts the long-term cost/benefit calculus.

As a result, homeownership may no longer be the bedrock of the “American Dream” for many — which could depress demand for new mortgages, refinancing, and home-related consumer spending.

Do you want to see how to make more plays? Do you want to find gains yourself?

Unusual Whales helps you find market opportunities through our market tide, historical options flow, GEX, and much, much more.

Create a free account here to start conquering the market with Unusual Whales:
https://unusualwhales.com/login?ref=blubber

Market & Economic Implications

🏗️ Stress on Housing, Construction & Home-Improvement Sectors

If fewer people feel comfortable buying or maintaining homes, companies focused on home-improvement products, appliances, maintenance services, and construction may see demand slow.

Conversely, rental-housing and property-management firms may see increased demand — but only if they can balance upkeep costs and rental rates.

📉 Reduced Consumer Spending on Big-Ticket Home Goods

Furniture, appliances, renovation supplies — all may suffer as homeowners tighten budgets. Less disposable income after taxes, maintenance, and insurance means fewer “nice-to-have” purchases.

📈 Pressure on Mortgage & Housing-Finance Markets

As carrying costs rise, refinances and new mortgage originations may slow. Some homeowners may even face affordability stress, which could impact defaults, refinancing volumes, and demand for mortgage-backed securities.

What This Means for Traders & Options Players

Stocks tied to real estate — homebuilders, REITs, home-improvement retailers — could see swings as affordability erodes and buyer sentiment shifts. Expect heightened implied volatility, especially around earnings or macro data releases.

Theme Shift: From Homeownership to Rentership

Watch for increased flow in REITs, rental-housing funds, and property-management firms. Downside pressure may hit discretionary home-goods retailers and companies dependent on new-home demand.

Credit, Insurance & Lending Exposure

Insurance providers, banks, and home-finance firms may face pressures if more households squeeze budgets or defer maintenance, creating risk of unanticipated claims, loan stress, or lower refinance demand. Those dynamics can show up in options volume surges.

Key Sectors & Stocks to Monitor (via Unusual Whales)

Track these name-groups to see where market pressure may build or where demand may shift:

Home-improvement retail and materials suppliers
Residential REITs and rental-housing operators
Mortgage lenders and housing-finance firms
Consumer-durable goods retailers (furniture, appliances, home goods)

Given rising hidden costs, shifts in consumption and demand could ripple through these sectors — especially once rate cycles, taxes, or macro surprises hit.

The Takeaway: Homeownership Just Got Riskier — Plan Accordingly

Owning a home is no longer just about down payments and mortgage rates. Insurance, taxes, maintenance, and upkeep are stacking up — and they’re rising faster than income.

For first-time buyers and long-term owners alike, that means you need a bigger financial buffer. Buying a home without accounting for ongoing costs might turn what’s supposed to be an asset into a heavy liability.

For the market and traders, it’s a structural shift — and one that could change demand curves for real estate, housing, and home-centered consumption for years.

Want to Track These Housing-Driven Market Shifts in Real Time?

Get ahead of volatility, sector rotations, and shifting demand with Unusual Whales tools.
Sign up for a free account now:
https://unusualwhales.com/login?ref=blubber