Bessent: US Doesn't Need as Many Jobs After Deportations, Border Closure

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has a new framing for the weakening US labor market: the country simply doesn’t need as many jobs anymore. Speaking on CNBC, Bessent said the jobs being created are going to Americans, and that after the deportations under the Trump administration and the closing of the border, the US doesn’t need to produce as many jobs.

What Bessent actually said

Bessent was asked whether the most recent jobs report was a sign of the US labor market cracking, and he replied that the data at the moment are quite noisy. He then pivoted to immigration policy as the reason weaker prints should not concern investors.

His remarks shifted the focus from the administration’s campaign argument that deportations would create opportunities for American workers to a broader argument that a smaller labor force requires fewer new jobs. Bessent also said what’s really important is that the US is seeing a manufacturing renaissance.

The jobs data behind the spin

The American economy lost 23,000 jobs last month, according to federal data. Notably, women accounted for 100 percent of that decline, losing 32,000 jobs while men gained 9,000.

The unemployment rate for US-born workers increased to 4.6% in July from 4.3% when Donald Trump took office in January. That undercuts the argument that a tighter labor supply is automatically translating into gains for domestic workers.

Do you want to see how to make more plays? Do you want to find gains yourself?

Unusual Whales helps you find market opportunities through our market tide, historical options flow, GEX, and much, much more.

Create a free account here to start conquering the market with Unusual Whales.

Why the framing matters for markets

The pitch resets the bar for what a “good” payrolls print looks like. Peter Navarro previously said people should expect job growth in the 50,000 monthly range, rather than the six-figure range seen during the Biden administration, arguing that when the US was letting in 2 million illegal aliens, it had to produce 200,000 jobs a month for steady state.

For traders, that matters because it changes how the Fed, the dollar, and rates markets read the labor data. A shrinking workforce plus soft hiring can still show up as a low unemployment rate, muddying the case for cuts even if growth is stalling.

The credibility problem

Economist Tony Yates observed that Bessent’s spin on the jobs report undermined one of the Trump administration’s rationales for carrying out mass deportations, writing that it contradicts the argument that migrants were stealing jobs from everyone else and that the claim now is that the jobs were created by migrants just as they are now gone with them.

Labor-market researchers and immigration analysts have warned that mass deportations could reduce the number of available workers at a time when employers continue to report hiring challenges, with Stuart Anderson of the National Foundation for American Policy noting that without immigrants and their children, the US would have seen little labor-force growth in recent years. See more coverage on Unusual Whales news.

Options market and stocks to watch

Watch for reactions in names most exposed to labor supply, consumer demand, and the “manufacturing renaissance” narrative Bessent is pushing.

• WMT: Watch for continued pressure on retail after the recent tape, with a softening jobs backdrop weighing on the low-end consumer.
• CAT: Watch as a bellwether for whether the manufacturing renaissance claim shows up in orders and guidance.
• DIS and MAR: Watch travel and leisure names for signs the labor cooldown is bleeding into discretionary spend.
• XLF: Watch financials for repricing of Fed cut odds if soft payrolls keep printing alongside sticky inflation.

Want more market intelligence? Create your free Unusual Whales account for options flow, market tide, GEX, and the full toolkit.